Craig and Sandy McCathie

Phone: +61 8 8682 2166


The Fresh Fish Place owners Craig McCathie and Sandy Harder are passionate about delivering the best seafood experience to their visitors.

What began as a family partnership in 1991 has expanded into a vision of grand seafood culinary tourism. The Proper Bay Road business is teeming with seafood experiences that range from fresh seafood and fish and chips, to seafood cooking classes and behind-the-scenes factory tours.

Fresh crayfish / rock lobster at The Fresh Fish Place

From New Zealand to Cactus

Craig’s journey to developing an award-winning seafood wholesale retail business started in the summer of 1982, during a surfing trip from his native New Zealand to Cactus, Penong, South Australia.

“At that time Tracks magazine, a surfing magazine, was what everyone read, and Cactus featured quite frequently in those days,” Craig said.

“Cactus had a lot of appeal because it was isolated in a desert. There was great surf and no one else there, because no one in their right mind would live there.” Its isolation shared some similarities with parts of the coast near Wellington where he learnt to surf.

Craig’s trip around Australia in search of surf was a youthful whim, but the reality was he soon needed money to survive.


Experienced pole fisherman

“I heard about the tuna season, so I came down from Cactus to Port Lincoln and got a job at Port Lincoln Tuna Processors,” Craig said.

“I was with a friend, and we decided if we worked at Tuna Processors we would know when the boats were coming in. It was only a matter of a couple of weeks and I got my first job on a tuna boat.”

That was on the fishing vessel Bonanza, and Frank Pirrello was the skipper.

“It was a pole boat, and Frank had asked if I poled tuna. I lied and said ‘yes’ to get the job,” he recalled. “So we went out fishing south of Rocky Island, and after I went into the racks to pole tuna for the first time, Frank said, ‘You’ve never poled tuna before, have you?’

Craig-McCathie pole fishing for tuna

“I admitted I hadn’t, and he said it was lucky we weren’t close to shore because he would have put me overboard to swim. Needless to say, I learnt pretty fast how to pole tuna.”

It was a great way to earn a living for a young man in his early 20s.

“Poling tuna in the 80s was a fantastic time. Tuna fishermen from all around the world would converge on Port Lincoln in November, then work hard for a long season.

“Not having much opportunity to spend our pay, at the end of the season we walked away with most of our earnings to play hard in the off season.

“I would then head back to New Zealand to work in the ski areas in the Southern Lakes region, where all the action was.

“I had the most amazing life in the 80s, coming back every season for the tuna until about 1991 when tuna ranching was starting.”

Craig McCathie commercial tuna fishing

A new life closer to shore

Craig had explored other fisheries during some of the off seasons, but it was while orange roughy fishing off Tasmania that he decided to find a safer way to earn a living.

“Having seen a colleague nearly washed overboard in horrendous conditions, I made a life-changing decision to come back to Port Lincoln and buy an inshore fishing licence that I could work daily,” he said. “

I purchased a marine-scale fish licence and targeted blue crabs at Port Wakefield and Franklin Harbour, and sand crabs at Coffin Bay.”

While it was the end of his deep sea fishing career, it did not provide the lifestyle he had hoped for.

“Lots of it was night work, and to be a successful marine-scale fishermen you have to be on call seven days a week in order to get at least four to five days’ fishing to survive.

“It was a great experience, but after 10 years, I had begun to want a change.”

Craig-McCathie-commercial-crab-fishing Venus-Bay


Dry land partnership

At the end of 1999 Craig and wife Sandy went into a fish-factory partnership with brother-in-law Mark Carr and Sandy’s sister Sharlene.

“We took the plunge, not really knowing it would change our lives,” Craig said.

“I am eternally grateful to my brother-in-law, as I feel fishing is a young man’s game, and this has opened a whole new world for me.

“It was a leap of faith, but it has been a timely opportunity to stay involved in the fishing industry while learning small-business skills.

“I am now totally immersed in the world of small business – I live it, and breathe it.

“I have 22 employees, and my role is to try to keep a small business going to ensure those people have jobs.

“I have learnt a whole new set of skills. For the first six years I worked from the ground up, from sweeping floors to building up the food service division, but not a lot on the management side. When our partners sold out and we took sole ownership, management was another very steep learning curve.”

A vision becomes reality

In 2011 the couple started making plans to expand the retail section of the business.

“From the start we were involved with the Eyre Peninsula Aquaculture & Seafood Trail with our factory tours, and we had realized the potential for growth in the tourism sector in Port Lincoln,” Craig said.

“At the time we could see the popularity of reality TV cooking shows, and what we had was a kind of ‘perfect storm’: emerging culinary tourism, a growing baby- boomer population of Grey Nomads, a new 110-room hotel, Makybe Diva, adventure tourism, shark cage diving and everything else Port Lincoln had to offer acted like forces of nature to drive more and more visitors to Port Lincoln.

“Our vision was to create a retail store with the complete ‘Ocean to Plate’ seafood experience,” Craig said. To accommodate their growing needs, they built a new 180m-square new retail store, upgrading from a 20m area.

A healthy occupation

Craig is most passionate about selling a product that is healthy. “We are dealing with a product that can improve people’s well-being.

“I totally believe in our products. Whether it be a fresh fish fillet, a flathead wrap, a cooking class or educating tourists in our factory tours about our seafood industry, we endeavour to provide a great seafood experience.”

He is excited to be a part of Eyre Peninsula’s food brand, sharing promotion with people who are also passionate about what they do – and in a beautiful part of the country.

And for Craig, Eyre Peninsula’s coastline hasn’t lost any of the wild ruggedness that first attracted him to Cactus just over three decades ago.